In spite of all the good things about organically grown crops like drought resistance, higher nutritive value, and increased pest resistance, a lot of farmers still operate by the old-fashioned industrial methods. What are the major drawbacks that are holding back so many farmers from switching over to a clearly better farming method? Let us take a look.
Productivity
Advocates of industrial farming point out to the superior productivity of their method. It is possible to get a much higher crop yield by using massive amounts of chemicals and machinery, working over huge blank fields with a single crop. However, the productivity advantages dwindle over time. You would find a lot of old farmers who remark on how much richer the crops and pastures were in their youth.
Industrial practices thrash the land and diminish the soil life till it can no longer convert the available organic matter to soil fertility. Productivity wanes, and bolstering it by using more chemicals is akin to flogging a dead horse. Since organic farming relies on the life of the soil to build fertility, its benefits are fundamental to its methods. It is possible to scale up the operations if more farmers convert to organic methods.
Cultivation
While industrial farmers sow their crop by directly drilling the seed into soil treated with herbicide, organic farmers depend on cultivation to remove the weeds before they sow. Compared to cultivation, direct drilling does not disrupt the soil structure. It also lowers the risk of the soil being lost to water or wind erosion. This is a valid point if the soil quality is poor.
However, you need to bear in mind that soil that is deadened by chemicals is weakened heavily by the loss of soil life and is incapable of maintaining its integrity even under occasional cultivation. So, if you look at it, it is a circular argument that leads nowhere. If the soil is structurally sound, you can cultivate it regularly without incurring damage, particularly if it is well protected by windbreaks and Keyline conservation measures.
GM crops
Organic farmers do not use genetically engineered or modified food crops, most of which are designed to tolerate herbicides or resist pests. Industrial farmers, however, are free to take advantage of the GM crops as they please. The productivity gains that are usually attributed to genetically modified crops are negligible, especially once you factor in the experience of the farmer, the growing conditions, and the different soil types.
What no one likes to mention is that most of the farmers use these crops only for convenience. There are growing indications that GM crops might be harmful to both the environment and human health. Once they are released on a large scale, it is not possible to undo it.
Time
Organic farming requires a greater level of interaction between the farmer and his crop for purposes of observation, weed control, and timely intervention. It is more labor intensive compared to mechanical/chemical agriculture, and a farmer can produce much more crop by the use of industrial methods than he/she could by completely utilizing organic methods.
Skill
You need a lot of skill to organically grow your crop. However, since professional farming of any kind imparts an observant and close relationship to living things, you would find that the best organic farmers are the ones who have converted from agrichemical farming. Organic farmers do not have handy chemical fixes on their shelf for all their problems. They have to engage in careful observation and understand how to tweak their system to correct the cause of a problem instead of treating the effect.
This is a big issue in the transition period from conventional to fully organic farming when there is a peak in the learning curve and all the transition-related problems. It takes a lot of time to build a healthy farming ecosystem which can cope on its own without the intervention of synthetic aides.